Thursday, October 04, 2012

How fast do the wheels of justice turn?

On the same day that a man under the age of 60  is condemned to death in a Thai Court of First Instance, he is shackled. The shackles are welded to his ankles and are intended to remain until his execution or until the death sentence is rejected by a Court of Appeal, the Supreme Court, or by a Royal Pardon. In a judgement made by the Administrative Court such shackling is illegal and prohibited by the Thai Constitution. The judgement has been appealed by the Department of Corrections, three years have passed without a response from the Appeal Court, during which time the prisoner concerned has remained shackled.
In shackling prisoners the wheels of 'justice' turn very fast indeed.
However, when prisoners benefit from a Royal Pardon, the wheels of Justice turn slowly. A recent proclamation of Commutation of Sentence, dated 11th August, allows 90 days for its implementation. Which is hardly intended to mean that a delay of 90 days is mandatory or even advisable. Prisoners are assured by well meaning officials that the shackles will be removed, perhaps tomorrow. Is this extra frustration for a prisoner who has been shackled for years necessary or tolerable?   

Saturday, September 01, 2012

Chalerm and the Way of Death


Death no deterrent

Re: ''Critics of swift drug executions blasted'' (BP, Aug 30).

In pursuing his campaign to hurry to the execution chamber prisoners condemned to death on drug-related charges, Deputy Prime Minister Chalerm Yubamrung appears to ignore the implications of the recent royal pardon extended to all prisoners condemned to death, for whom legal process is complete. Of the 58 people who have been pardoned, 37 were condemned on drug-related charges.

The Chalerm proposal to execute them within 15 days of an Appeal Court sentence, was already a travesty of national and international law, which still allowed submission to the Supreme Court, and the prerogative of the procedure of royal pardon. On a previous effort to accelerate executions initiated by Justice Minister Pracha Promnok, the Corrections Department had declared the legitimacy of waiting for a royal response. To their great credit the Corrections Department rejected the proposal of swift execution by the minister, quoting their right to act only on the delivery of the royal decision.

While Chalerm is to be lauded for his successes in seizing drugs and lowly carriers in the current campaign, he has still to capture the drug lords who are behind the whole drug trade. There is ample evidence that the death penalty is not a deterrent to the drug trade, nor according to international law, as interpreted by the United Nations Human Rights Council, does it even constitute a valid punishment for drug-related crimes. In fact, the death penalty is being recognised as an irrelevant and disproportionate response to all crimes. But in a Thai context, and with respect to royal prerogatives in Thailand, the attempt of Chalerm to preempt royal pardons is odious. If Chalerm had his way, none of the 37 pardoned people would have lived to benefit from this reaffirmation of the value of all human life and the opportunity to rebuild their lives. I suggest that he respects humane practices and announces a rejection of the way of death he is attempting to install.

DANTHONG BREEN
The Union for Civil LIberty

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

All death sentences for which legal procedures are completed, to be commuted to life imprisonment by royal pardon


It is reported from a prison source that an announcement was made this morning in Bang Kwang prison that all prisoners condemned to death and whose legal procedures are completed, will benefit from a royal pardon; their death penalty sentences will be commuted to life imprisonment. Confirmed by publication in the Royal Gazette of 11th August, Article 14:
มาตรา ๑๔ นักโทษเด็ดขาดซึ่งต้องโทษประหารชีวิต ให้ได้รับพระราชทานอภัยโทษลดโทษ
ลงเป็นโทษจําคุกตลอดชีวิต
This is a momentous event which may be the beginning of the end for the death penalty in Thailand

Wednesday, August 08, 2012

USA: a mentally retarded person executed in Texas despite protests


Marvin Wilson, African American convicted of murder in 1998, was finally executed Tuesday in Texas. He had a mental age of seven years. In the afternoon, the Supreme Court of the United States rejected a last resort by his lawyers.
This African American, 54, who was convicted in 1998 for a murder committed in 1992, was pronounced dead by lethal injection at 18:27 local time.

Several organizations defending human rights had protested this execution. Among them, Amnesty International said that the Supreme Court decision not to postpone the execution was "particularly disturbing". In 2004, Marvin Wilson had been diagnosed as mildly mentally retarded. Amnesty said that he had an IQ of 61.

Before his execution, he addressed members of his family, assuring them he loved them. "Take me home, Jesus, take me home, Lord," he also said, according to comments reported to AFP by a spokesman for the Prison Services of Texas. Then, turning again to his family, he concluded: "I love you all. I'm ready."

In 2002, the Supreme Court of the United States prohibited the execution of mentally retarded convicts who, because their disability, "would run the risk of wrongful execution". But the Court has never given a precise definition of mental retardation, leaving each state to set requirements to determine the level of disability intended by the prohibition. According to the criteria in force in Texas, Marvin Wilson did not suffer from mental disability.

Already on July 18 , Yokamon Hearn, a Black American, 34, was executed in Texas, despite evidence of mental disorder since childhood, and many protests. On July 23, however, the execution of a condemned man also suffering from a mental disorder was suspended in Georgia (southeast), two hours before the fatal time. The suspension was granted not because of mental disorder but on account of a technicality relating to a change in the procedure of lethal injection. US justice appreciates the niceties of technical efficiency rather than arguments relating to humanity.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Toshi Kazama in Bangkok

From 15th to 19th July, Japanese photographer Toshi Kazama, renowned for his photographs of young people who are condemned to death, was in Bangkok. He visited and met with prisoners who had been condemned to death in Bang Kwang prison. On the evening of the 17th he showed a selection of his work in the Foreign Correspondent's Club of Thailand. More significantly, on the 18th he addressed a meeting of government officials in the Department of Liberties and Human Rights of the Ministry of Justice, the office which is preparing the proposal to parliament on abolition of the death penalty in Thailand.
The message of Toshe Kazama is the value of human life. His images show the humanity of the condemned who are indistinguishable from young people around us. He engages with these young people, but engages equally with the families of murder victims. He reveals the surprising experience that all the families, whatever their initial anger against the murderers,  come in time to realise that vengeance cannot satisfy their pain, and reject capital punishment. The depth of healing they experience comes not from the execution of the perpetrator, but from forgiveness which releases them from a cycle of bitterness and hatred.

Thursday, July 12, 2012

Chicanary

Is there no end to US chicanery on the death penalty? To give credit where it is due, the NYT is tireless in tracking down examples of indifference to the value of one human life.
Thailand, in revising laws regarding Capital Punishment, beware of taking the US as an example.

An Urgent Plea for Mercy
Published: July 6, 2012 Editorial, New York Times
The Supreme Court banned the death penalty for mentally retarded offenders a decade ago, but Georgia apparently has not gotten the message. It is the only state with a statute requiring a defendant to meet the unfairly heavy burden of proving retardation beyond a reasonable doubt. This stringent standard could be readily manipulated by experts, resulting in unconstitutional executions.
In a closely divided 4-to-3 ruling, the State Supreme Court wrongly upheld the statute on the grounds that the United States Supreme Court left it to the states to set procedures for deciding on retardation. This unjust procedural requirement effectively denies protection for the mentally impaired, as required by the Eighth Amendment.
This week, Georgia issued a warrant to execute Warren Lee Hill Jr., a death-row inmate convicted of murder, who has an I.Q. of 70. The Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles is the fail-safe in the state’s criminal justice system, with a mandate to exercise mercy when the court system has failed to come to a just result. That is clearly true in this case. The trial judge found that Mr. Hill was mentally retarded by applying the fairer “preponderance of the evidence” standard in determining his mental impairment.
The State Supreme Court, however, ruled that Mr. Hill had to prove his mental retardation beyond a reasonable doubt. The dissent rightly argued that applying the tougher standard is unconstitutional because it imposes too high a risk that a court’s conclusion will be wrong. The dissent relied on the United States Supreme Court holding that it is unconstitutional to require a defendant to prove that he is incompetent to stand trial by any standard higher than a preponderance of the evidence.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit avoided correcting the state court’s stark constitutional error, claiming that a federal statute on habeas corpus review imposes severe limits so that Mr. Hill had to show “that no fair-minded jurist” could agree with the Georgia court. The United States Supreme Court denied a review of Mr. Hill’s case in June. He is scheduled for execution this month.
Jurors from this case said they would have sentenced Mr. Hill to life without parole if they had had the option. The family of the victim has said Mr. Hill should not be executed. The pardon board has the discretion and the duty to commute his sentence to life without parole. The legal and factual record strongly compels that just decision.

Monday, July 09, 2012

Singapore Yields Grudgingly on Death Penalty

Singapore which claims success in countering drug trafficking and ascribes the supposed success to its practice of mandatory death sentencing,  yields in exempting certain cases from mandatory death sentences. Academic studies have long disproved the effectiveness of executions in countering crime. But it appears that Singapore is finally forced to admit that mandatory executions are inappropriate when confronted with the inhumane absurdity of the practice. 
The death penalty will be changed, allowing judges discretion to impose life imprisonment in certain specific instances of drug trafficking and murder. The announcement of the change in policy says that the leniency will apply to mere couriers of drugs, not the drug kingpins and distributors. But when has Singapore succeeded in arresting the higher echelons of the drug trade, rather than the fumbling nervous couriers?
The relaxation of mandatory death sentences will apply under two conditions:
"First, the trafficker must have only played the role of courier, and must not have been involved in any other activity related to the supply or distribution of drugs. Second, discretion will only apply if having satisfied this first requirement, either the trafficker has cooperated with the Central Narcotics Bureau in a substantive way, or he has a mental disability which substantially impairs his appreciation of the gravity of the act."

But we must not think that Singapore is embracing any quality of mercy. The mandatory death sentence will be replaced by life sentence in prison, and caning. Singapore's executioner used to comfort those whom he was about to dispatch to a 'better life", by assuring them that their fate was preferable to life imprisonment in Singapore's jail. He may have been right. But just to give an extra tilt to the balance of justice, the new sentence throws in a measure of the abominable practice of caning, a process which leaves everlasting scars on the body, marks of degradation and reprisal. 

Singapore provides an elaborate cover story to justify its changes in sentencing. In reality the steps leading to the change are:
1. The contradictions in practice. While Singapore claims that the basis of its capital punishment policy is deterrence, the statistics of executions are hidden, no doubt to inculcate fear while maintaining a benign face.
2. Claims that Singapore justice is equal for all have been discounted The rich and well connected can escape sentence. The poor and unrepresented are hanged
3. The increasing juridical isolation of Singapore in its claim to be democratic while denying the right to life.
4. All of these faults of justice have come to a head in the case of the young Malaysian, Yong Vui Kong, arrested at the age of 19 whose story is told below in a posting made on May 25th last. Protest and outrage has been expressed across the world at the seeming certain execution of this young man. At last Singapore has found a way out. Yong Vu Kong is likely to be the first to escape execution, and relieve Singapore of acute embarasment.


We do not thank you Singapore for this concession, the alternative you offer is a regression and further diminution of respect for human rights.

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Notes on beatings in Thai jails

Searches and Attacks in Bangkwang and other prisons
Attacks on prisoners by outside forces, on 16th and 17th May 2012
Searches were made throughout Bangkwang prison in Nonthabure, on the evenings of 16th and 17th May. Bangkwang prison is located in Nonthaburi, where those serving sentences over 30 years are held, and those condemned to death. Reports told of beatings “without apparent reason” carried out by a special masked unit.

The first attack on prisoners was made by a group of blue uniformed persons wearing caps, identified by the prisoners as ‘police’. In the floor on which our informant was detained there were about 20 prisoners, the floor consisted of 24 such rooms of facing cells. At first they heard sounds of beating, shouts, and screams. The assailants moved from room to room, apparently carrying out beatings on every floor of every building. They carried batons and numbered from fifty to a hundred or more. Prisoners were made to squat on the floor while searches were carried out. Apart from the blue clad ‘police’, there were ‘officials’ wearing white tea shirts, possibly military or corrections department officials, and a special masked squad dressed in black. Attacks on prisoners appeared to be random; they reported that one prisoner, a Thai citizen, had been beaten to death, and another seriously injured, with a cracked skull, when telephones were found in their bed area. Our informant was kicked on the legs as he crouched on the ground. In another building an informant told us that the prisoners were warned in advance by their own warders to hide telephones, which they did by attaching them behind fans. Prisoners remarked that if the search had been made by warders themselves these phones would have easily been discovered. His account of the beatings corresponded to that of a prisoner in a separate building for prisoners condemned to death. Beatings carried out by masked assailants lasted about 90 minutes. A police man stood at the door of each cell while the occupants were being beaten. On one occasion a regular prison guard was heard calling for a doctor to come. On the following morning he observed two prisoners showing extensive wounds on their backs.

In one account the prisoners were addressed the following morning by a recently appointed prison governor, warning them that news of the previous night’s events were not to spread outside the prison. However, warders advised prisoners to tell their relatives during visits and called on them to make complaints. It was clear that regular prison staff were against these beatings by outside forces.

Reports in the Thai press report other “visits” by such a mysterious unit in Nakhon Sri Thammarat prison. Authorities claimed the events were to eliminate mobile telephones and drugs from the prison. They admitted that prisoners were out of control of permanent staff who feared retaliation to themselves and their families by outside contacts of prisoners who had discovered their identities and domiciles. 

From Bom Bak Phiset prison
An account of similar beatings has been received from prisoners in Bam Bak prison in both Thai and English versions. The following is the verbatim English version.

“Our Complaint to Foreign Embassies and to the Correctional Department

On 9th May 2012 Thai correctional officers conducted a raid on Building 9 of Bom Bak prison looking for “illegal belongings”.
This search was completely different from all previous searches carried out by the relevant authorities.
These officers used extreme violence and brutality and threatening behaviour. They repeatedly hit, punched and kicked vulnerable inmates who were all passive. Hundreds of victims required hospital treatment after the cowardly assaults.
These actions are illegal under existing Thai law. This leads to the question of why are high ranking Thai government officials ordering such illegal and horrific orders.
Therefore the foreign prisoners of building 9 urgently request that our embassies are informed of the truth about the illegal incidents so that necessary steps can be taken to ensure their safety.
Thanking you for these considerations
                        Foreign nationalities from building 9
                        Bom Bat Piset”

The statement was signed by 95 foreign prisoners from 17 different countries. Doubtless Thai prisoners were afraid to sign.

Note: All prisons in Thailand are chronically overcrowded and understaffed. It appears impossible for prison authorities to prevent prisoners accessing mobile phones, drugs, and gambling paraphernalia. Recently all gifts of food or other material brought by visitors have been banned so that smuggling by corrupt officials is the only conduit. A mobile phone inside the prison sells for ten times the outside price. Drugs appear to be readily available.
The populations of the prisons mentioned above are:
Bangkwang; 4008  prisoners
Nakorn Sri Thammarat; 3,202 prisoners
Bombot Prison; 3912 prisoners
Department of Statistics 1st April 2012

Update, Thailand Death Penalty Statistics


Death Penalty Statistics of Thailand for 19th June 2012

All cases

Gender
Appeal Court
Supreme Court
Court Procedure Complete
Total
Male
328
274
52
654
Female
55
11
6
72
Total
383
285
58
728


Drug related cases
Gender
Appeal Court
Supreme Court
Court Procedure Complete
Total
Male
156
89
31
276
Female
45
10
6
61
Total
201
99
37
337


Homicide and other cases
Gender
Appeal Court
Supreme Court
Court Procedure Complete
Total
Male
172
185
21
378
Female
10
1
0
11
Total
182
186
21
389

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

If the Innocent are Executed?


At last there is closure to one of the saddest misjudgments in judicial history.
In 1980 the two month old child of Linda Chamberlain was killed in an atrocious manner while the parents of the child were on a camping holiday near Ayer’s Rock in Central Australia. The parents of the child were arrested and charged with the murder. In their defence they claimed that the child had been taken by a dingo, an Australian wild dog. But the prosecution claimed that the awful wounds on the child’s body had been caused by a scissors to simulate the claws and fangs of a dog. In the very emotional climate that followed news of the child’s death, the mother was found guilty and sentenced to thirty years imprisonment with forced labour. Her partner, accused as an accomplice, escaped with a suspended sentence. But Linda Chamberlain continued to protest her innocence, and three years after sentencing the mother was released from prison on the finding of clothes of the infant near the lair of a dingo, which supported Linda’s claim. But popular opinion still considered her a murderess and she suffered continual attacks and insults.
On the 12th June of this year, a court has finally ruled that the death was indeed caused by a dingo. The mother still raises questions of her conviction on the energetic charge that she was the killer, by police who were eager to satisfy public opinion at the time.
At last justice is done. Comments on the story in newspaper columns are mostly asking, why the fuss about an event which happened long ago in a far off place. But one commentator asked:
“A small reminder for supporters of the death penalty: that crime created an emotional climate in which the mother was found guilty of murder and sentenced to 30 years hard labour. And if she had been condemned to death? Could she be brought back to life today to receive justice?”

                            Mother Linda and her child Azaria
If there were no other argument against the death penalty, this story would suffice to put an end to it. We are always met with indignant questions that follow a savage killing; is the murderer to escape retribution for his crime? No, the murderer must not escape punishment. But should not the execution of a person who is possibly innocent outweigh the supposed satisfaction of a revenge matching the savagery of a crime? The outcome reveals human fallibility. What seems certain is never so. And even if the judgement approaches the near certainty of a public event, what is the benefit of matching one atrocity with another, killing a perpetrator to prove that killing is wrong?